After the first part in which i've highlighted what i mostly like about the WP OS, here i am with this second part where you'll find what still confuses me or don't like it at all on the WP experience and on the lumia 800 specifically :
- It doesn't feel like it's a Nokia device ! a Nokia operating system ! i don't find roots for Nokia device, it feels stranger ! this feeling is in the same time good and bad, good because it's new experience, new identity to Nokia experience overall, but loyal Nokia user base will need time to get used to that experience and to deal with absence with some very basic options or settings...that still confuses me and pushes me to not using it as my main device...read after the break :
- Call history doesn't show call duration ! Come ON ! Or if the call is a week old, it doesn't show the calling (received or dialed) hour ! Are you kidding? No one among Microsoft design or dev team though about this basics features, this a PHONE before all, a Nokia PHONE !
- For a phone that’s so integrated with Facebook – there is no support for facebook notifications (even with the latest facebook standalone app update), my N9 will enable this in the imminent upcoming update (PR1.2).
- Contacts fields for phone numbers isn't usable at all, neither customizable ...what a headache to modify a land-line number to a mobile number...
- Bing Local search doesn’t work in Morocco (and a whole lot of other countries) and Bing classical search results is...let me say this in other words, if you use Google you'll get 100 results relating to your search query, with bing, you'll only have (non pertinent) 30 or 50 results...
- WP7 doesn’t support xvid/divx and other common movie codecs.
- You can’t quickly skip forward in songs/movies by dragging a slider. Instead, you need to keep tapping or holding the “fast-forward” button.
- Tethering support? You can forget about that for now...my N9 does that (my iPhone and even my N8 with dedicated app).
- Email, oh, yeah, which phone cannot do email? WP fails when it comes to sharing/attaching contents, you can only send pics as attachment, if you want to send office docs, you need to go to office, open the doc, and choose share, too simple, right? In your dream...
- Sharing options by default are limited to facebook, email, twitter...i like N9 approach much better, in fact the more you install app that "support" sharing feature, it will be extended to other natives app but not all...
- HTML5 is the future, ok but the transition will take a little time from adobe flash, so you have to know that WP does not support flash in its browser. Microsoft announced that it too will abandon Flash as a default in its upcoming Windows 8 operating system... Android OS (symbian, maemo and few others) will do the job for sometime from now...
- BlueTooth File Transfer? Forget about that, you cannot share or transfer files via bluetooth like you can with other Nokia (Symbian, Maemo) or Android devices, welcome to iOS world...
- Ability to upload files? Forget about that, you do not have free access to upload file types to websites except for pictures files.You cannot select PDF, audio files such as mp3, wmv, etc., video files, office documents, on any other type of file that is not a picture file to upload, GOD we are living on which century?!
- Multitasking : The meaning of multitasking in Windows Phone is slightly different from the multitasking we are all used to. It means executing function while our application is not running in foreground, if you own a symbian or maemo device (N900, N9), the multitasking experience on the lumia 800 will be a jock, a BIG one ! in fact, my basic understanding is that it is sort of like Android, iOS...task management paradigm, it makes use of frozen app states to conserve memory and prevent a background app from running away with all the CPU cycles, in fact, apps are Suspended and kept in RAM for quick resume but not actively processed. They can also be cleared from memory automatically as soon as it is needed for something else,
- The other thing that really bothered me, that seems like a minor thing but became a legitimate frustration, is the menu bar. Almost, on every other device, you could look at the top of the screen and see the time, battery and network information, and connection status. That's not frivolous. Those things are important. Windows Phone does away with that. Sometimes, in some apps, you can see the time, and tap near it to see the battery life and connection status. In a lot of apps, you can't. Using Twitter and want to know what time it is? Go back to the homescreen. Then go back to Twitter, and wait for it to reload, because it doesn't support multitasking yet and had frozen into a hibernation state while you checked the time. This is really, really dumb ! You have to learn from N9 !
- Navigation GPS : nothing interesting to highlight, maps are not powered by Nokia Maps but by bing's ones, except on drive application, but even on drive application we are at 50% of N9 or symbian features...(POI, favorites etc.), no support of compass...
- If you want to download a unsupported file by windows phone (zip, rar etc.) the download will very simply fails...great...
- VOIP? Currently there is no VOIP support at all for windows phone 7...
- Front Facing Camera and Video Calling- no front facing cameras even if video calling applications such as Yahoo Messenger, Quik, and skype will be coming to the phone that will be USELESS !
- Lack of (quality) apps : Call blocker, sms blocker etc, no apps for that for now, my N8 is actually my main phone because of it has the best PIM tools of all OSs (except android at some level), whatsapp is very buggy, twitter is basic, etc. (however there are some good ones, like foursquare, tunewiki etc.) ! Add to that, not enough apps take advantage of Live Tiles...(yet)
- Message sync with the laptop (nokia suite fans) : you're dreaming !
- HDMI, TV Out, FM Transmitter? No chance !
- Application categorization. Sure, Ballmer hates the app-in app-out paradigm of other platforms, but that doesn’t mean the OS should not have app categories. Vertically growing app list becomes tiring to navigate after a while. And the only way they are sorted is alphabetic – which, needless to say, makes things even more difficult. Now even if you don’t want to have categories, why not sort apps automatically based on their usage? I mean, at least sort the top 10 and the rest can go in alphabetical order, or like on symbian belle, enable search and categories for apps, the best of both worlds ;)
- Camera : totally busted white balance and auto-exposure in low light scenes the continuous auto-focus is also not perfectly functional in video mode. It sometimes totally loose focus and get’s stuck unless you stop recording and start again. It hunts all over the place and I guess that it may be related to the previously mentioned white-balance and exposure issue (the auto-focus system is contrast based). There’s also too much grain in low light shots as if the auto-iso wasn’t correctly working either. Interestingly when things work as planned the shots are superb (no sharpening artifacts at all) and the videos are insane compared to other Windows Phones (and other unnamed devices..). One thing that I haven’t seen reported anywhere is that the Lumia 800 shoots / encodes videos at 14Mbps compared to 9Mbps -10Mbps on the HTC Titan (and 6MB/s on the first gen WP7 devices). The framerate also never goes below 25fps (up to 30fps) even in low light conditions unlike the Titan (and most other devices) which can drop as low as 15fps in some cases.
- Music quality isn't what you'd expect from a Nokia device, the sound is flat, no bass, no rich sound, my N9 (which also i criticized in this area) seems a lot better !
- The hardware search button is supposed to be context sensitive right? The hardware search button only ever goes to Bing search...
- And oh, wifi connection : it enters idle state once the device is locked (to preserve the battery) so don't expect push mails to work, unless the device is plugged into the charger !
- Last thing that drives me crazy : it hates 3G connection, i don't know if it's a bug, i didn't reset the device to check that but i remember it worked well at first week, i cannot check social news, apps or email under 3G connection (even if i forced the wifi to be disabled), only Internet explorer does work properly under 3G, weired...
Verdict? Stay tuned for the last part in a couple of days :)
- It doesn't feel like it's a Nokia device ! a Nokia operating system ! i don't find roots for Nokia device, it feels stranger ! this feeling is in the same time good and bad, good because it's new experience, new identity to Nokia experience overall, but loyal Nokia user base will need time to get used to that experience and to deal with absence with some very basic options or settings...that still confuses me and pushes me to not using it as my main device...read after the break :
- Call history doesn't show call duration ! Come ON ! Or if the call is a week old, it doesn't show the calling (received or dialed) hour ! Are you kidding? No one among Microsoft design or dev team though about this basics features, this a PHONE before all, a Nokia PHONE !
- For a phone that’s so integrated with Facebook – there is no support for facebook notifications (even with the latest facebook standalone app update), my N9 will enable this in the imminent upcoming update (PR1.2).
- Contacts fields for phone numbers isn't usable at all, neither customizable ...what a headache to modify a land-line number to a mobile number...
- Bing Local search doesn’t work in Morocco (and a whole lot of other countries) and Bing classical search results is...let me say this in other words, if you use Google you'll get 100 results relating to your search query, with bing, you'll only have (non pertinent) 30 or 50 results...
- WP7 doesn’t support xvid/divx and other common movie codecs.
- You can’t quickly skip forward in songs/movies by dragging a slider. Instead, you need to keep tapping or holding the “fast-forward” button.
- Tethering support? You can forget about that for now...my N9 does that (my iPhone and even my N8 with dedicated app).
- Email, oh, yeah, which phone cannot do email? WP fails when it comes to sharing/attaching contents, you can only send pics as attachment, if you want to send office docs, you need to go to office, open the doc, and choose share, too simple, right? In your dream...
- Sharing options by default are limited to facebook, email, twitter...i like N9 approach much better, in fact the more you install app that "support" sharing feature, it will be extended to other natives app but not all...
- HTML5 is the future, ok but the transition will take a little time from adobe flash, so you have to know that WP does not support flash in its browser. Microsoft announced that it too will abandon Flash as a default in its upcoming Windows 8 operating system... Android OS (symbian, maemo and few others) will do the job for sometime from now...
- BlueTooth File Transfer? Forget about that, you cannot share or transfer files via bluetooth like you can with other Nokia (Symbian, Maemo) or Android devices, welcome to iOS world...
- Ability to upload files? Forget about that, you do not have free access to upload file types to websites except for pictures files.You cannot select PDF, audio files such as mp3, wmv, etc., video files, office documents, on any other type of file that is not a picture file to upload, GOD we are living on which century?!
- Multitasking : The meaning of multitasking in Windows Phone is slightly different from the multitasking we are all used to. It means executing function while our application is not running in foreground, if you own a symbian or maemo device (N900, N9), the multitasking experience on the lumia 800 will be a jock, a BIG one ! in fact, my basic understanding is that it is sort of like Android, iOS...task management paradigm, it makes use of frozen app states to conserve memory and prevent a background app from running away with all the CPU cycles, in fact, apps are Suspended and kept in RAM for quick resume but not actively processed. They can also be cleared from memory automatically as soon as it is needed for something else,
- The other thing that really bothered me, that seems like a minor thing but became a legitimate frustration, is the menu bar. Almost, on every other device, you could look at the top of the screen and see the time, battery and network information, and connection status. That's not frivolous. Those things are important. Windows Phone does away with that. Sometimes, in some apps, you can see the time, and tap near it to see the battery life and connection status. In a lot of apps, you can't. Using Twitter and want to know what time it is? Go back to the homescreen. Then go back to Twitter, and wait for it to reload, because it doesn't support multitasking yet and had frozen into a hibernation state while you checked the time. This is really, really dumb ! You have to learn from N9 !
- Navigation GPS : nothing interesting to highlight, maps are not powered by Nokia Maps but by bing's ones, except on drive application, but even on drive application we are at 50% of N9 or symbian features...(POI, favorites etc.), no support of compass...
- If you want to download a unsupported file by windows phone (zip, rar etc.) the download will very simply fails...great...
- VOIP? Currently there is no VOIP support at all for windows phone 7...
- Front Facing Camera and Video Calling- no front facing cameras even if video calling applications such as Yahoo Messenger, Quik, and skype will be coming to the phone that will be USELESS !
- Lack of (quality) apps : Call blocker, sms blocker etc, no apps for that for now, my N8 is actually my main phone because of it has the best PIM tools of all OSs (except android at some level), whatsapp is very buggy, twitter is basic, etc. (however there are some good ones, like foursquare, tunewiki etc.) ! Add to that, not enough apps take advantage of Live Tiles...(yet)
- Message sync with the laptop (nokia suite fans) : you're dreaming !
- HDMI, TV Out, FM Transmitter? No chance !
- Application categorization. Sure, Ballmer hates the app-in app-out paradigm of other platforms, but that doesn’t mean the OS should not have app categories. Vertically growing app list becomes tiring to navigate after a while. And the only way they are sorted is alphabetic – which, needless to say, makes things even more difficult. Now even if you don’t want to have categories, why not sort apps automatically based on their usage? I mean, at least sort the top 10 and the rest can go in alphabetical order, or like on symbian belle, enable search and categories for apps, the best of both worlds ;)
- Camera : totally busted white balance and auto-exposure in low light scenes the continuous auto-focus is also not perfectly functional in video mode. It sometimes totally loose focus and get’s stuck unless you stop recording and start again. It hunts all over the place and I guess that it may be related to the previously mentioned white-balance and exposure issue (the auto-focus system is contrast based). There’s also too much grain in low light shots as if the auto-iso wasn’t correctly working either. Interestingly when things work as planned the shots are superb (no sharpening artifacts at all) and the videos are insane compared to other Windows Phones (and other unnamed devices..). One thing that I haven’t seen reported anywhere is that the Lumia 800 shoots / encodes videos at 14Mbps compared to 9Mbps -10Mbps on the HTC Titan (and 6MB/s on the first gen WP7 devices). The framerate also never goes below 25fps (up to 30fps) even in low light conditions unlike the Titan (and most other devices) which can drop as low as 15fps in some cases.
- Music quality isn't what you'd expect from a Nokia device, the sound is flat, no bass, no rich sound, my N9 (which also i criticized in this area) seems a lot better !
- The hardware search button is supposed to be context sensitive right? The hardware search button only ever goes to Bing search...
- And oh, wifi connection : it enters idle state once the device is locked (to preserve the battery) so don't expect push mails to work, unless the device is plugged into the charger !
- Last thing that drives me crazy : it hates 3G connection, i don't know if it's a bug, i didn't reset the device to check that but i remember it worked well at first week, i cannot check social news, apps or email under 3G connection (even if i forced the wifi to be disabled), only Internet explorer does work properly under 3G, weired...
Verdict? Stay tuned for the last part in a couple of days :)
